Welcome to Sign in | Join | Help
in
Home Blogs Forums Photos Calendar ABCActionNews.com

Flashpoint

Offshore oil drilling raises a slippery debate

By Brendan McLaughlin

The call to suspend the federal tax on gasoline over the summer was as transparent as it was dishonest. Depriving government of money to maintain highways in exchange for a few political points was a bad deal for everyone, but the damage would have been limited and short-lived.  The hysterical rush to erect oil derricks off Pass-a-Grille is likewise misguided, but generations would live with the results.

Like so many policy debates that devolve into partisan warfare, the casualty in this question of whether to lift the moratorium on offshore drilling  is common sense. Opening up select Gulf real estate to oil exploration within the current 125 mile limit may well be a smart investment. That won't happen though, because both sides have staked out the extreme positions of no new drilling vs.naming Daniel Day Lewis as Interior Secretary.

Attachment: Plainview.jpg (14057 bytes)

  The former oil executive running the country for the last seven years used the debate over our energy future to blame the democrats for the high price of gas and oil.   The president said:

"I know the Democratic leaders have opposed some of these policies in the past," Bush said. "Now that their opposition has helped drive gas prices to record levels, I ask them to reconsider their positions."

The accusation conjures the image of a vast ocean of sweet light crude being guarded by Nancy Pelosi herself, when in fact, oil companies are a long way from even exploring the additional acreage on and offshore, that have been opened up in the last several years.  The claim by John McCain that lifting the moratorium will bring short term price relief at the pumps has been so widely discredited that it strips the whole argument of credibility. Politicians from George Bush to John McCain to Charlie Crist to Mike Fasano obviously believe this issue is a winner. But as long as offshore drilling is sold as a curative to $4.00 a gallon gasoline, I think voters will be wary. After all, we're putting that expensive gas into our tanks. We're not sniffing the fumes.

Published Thursday, June 19, 2008 8:52 PM by Brendan
Attachment(s): Plainview.jpg

Comments

 

Jim Johnson said:

Brendan,

"The claim by John McCain that lifting the moratorium will bring short term price relief at the pumps has been so widely discredited that it strips the whole argument of credibility."

Some would point out the American public still find this credible, if you can believe the Rassmussen poll.  Moreover, you are giving too much credit to the American voter -- if politicians tell them gas prices will go down if they stop getting haircuts, barbers and stylists would be out of work.

The argument isn't whether prices will go down or not, it's when.

Truthfully, McCain's claim is blatantly misleading and another example of my party's failure to get a firm grasp of reality.
June 20, 2008 6:24 AM
 

Brendan said:

True that, Jim. The shame of it is that an honest representation of the risks and rewards of offshore drillling might result in a compromise that benefits all. I'm not holding my breath.
June 20, 2008 10:27 AM
 

Debbie said:

So you want to risk our tourist industry for gas we won't get for at least 10 - 14 years?  Are you crazy?  If it is really all about supply and demand, cut the demand, not the supply.  
1. Get rid of your gas guzzling, road hogging SUVs!  This will save our roads, eliminate many traffic jams, and lower demand for gas.
2. Carpool.
3. Move closer to your job.
4. Check your tire inflation.
5. Drive the speed limit and don't drive aggressively.

When you've done all these things, then talk to me about oil rigs lining our horizon.
June 20, 2008 12:58 PM
 

nancy brown said:

why did you not have\someone armed with facts and figures to balance one note fasano? with all due respect to the nice lady from the serria club, a more agressive person would have perhaps pointed out the vast difference between fact and fiction. nancy
June 22, 2008 10:42 AM
Anonymous comments are disabled

This Blog

Post Calendar

<June 2008>
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
25262728293031
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293012345

Syndication

Powered by Community Server, by Telligent Systems
Inergize Digital Media This site powered by Inergize Digital Media. The views expressed here do not necessarily reflect the views of this station.